Time studies and task mining represent two distinct methodologies for understanding and improving productivity and managing process intelligence. Traditional time studies involve manual observation and data collection to analyze how employees spend their time. In contrast, task mining leverages AI-driven tools to monitor digital interactions and digital workflows, uncovering inefficiencies and opportunities for improvement.

The Evolution of Work Analysis

Modern workplaces are complex ecosystems combining physical tasks and digital workflows. While traditional time studies once sufficed, they often fall short in today’s fast-paced, technology-driven environments. Nevertheless, time studies still hold relevance in certain contexts, particularly when used alongside advanced tools like task mining.

The Limitations of Traditional Time Studies

Time studies have been widely used for decades, but they come with several drawbacks in today’s work environment:

Invasiveness and Employee Distrust. Direct observation and self-reporting can make employees feel scrutinized and anxious. This often leads to altered behaviors (the Hawthorne Effect), reducing the reliability of the data collected.

Limited Scope and Static Data. Time studies capture a snapshot of activities during a specific period, failing to account for evolving workflows, seasonal fluctuations, or technological changes.

Bias and Human Error. Human involvement in data collection could introduce potential inaccuracies, whether through unintentional errors or deliberate misreporting by employees.

Inability to Capture Digital Complexity. Traditional methods struggle to keep pace with digital workflows, where employees navigate multiple applications and systems to complete tasks.

The Rise of Task Mining and AI-Driven Insights

Task mining automates the collection and analysis of digital workflow data. By monitoring user interactions across business applications, task mining provides actionable insights into task durations, bottlenecks, and inefficiencies.

Key Advantages of Task Mining

Automated and Unbiased Data Collection. Task mining reduces bias and increases accuracy.

Holistic View of Workflows. It captures interactions across multiple applications, providing a comprehensive understanding of digital tasks.

Real-Time and Continuous Monitoring. Unlike static time studies, task mining offers ongoing insights, helping organizations adapt to changing workflows.

Enhanced Privacy and Security. By focusing on whitelisted business applications, task mining ensures GDPR compliance and alleviates employee concerns about privacy.

Use Cases for Task Mining and AI Tools

Task mining and AI tools are revolutionizing how organizations understand and improve their workflows. These technologies offer powerful insights across industries by analyzing digital interactions, identifying inefficiencies, and streamlining processes. Here’s how they transform various business areas:

Enterprise Workflows. In large organizations with complex digital ecosystems, task mining uncovers inefficiencies by analyzing workflows across departments and applications. This comprehensive view enables leaders to pinpoint bottlenecks and implement process improvements with precision.

Customer Support and Service. By monitoring how representatives handle support tickets across platforms such as CRMs and email, task mining identifies delays, redundancies, and best practices. These insights enable customer service teams to streamline workflows, reduce response times, and improve overall customer satisfaction.

Financial Services. Banks and financial institutions streamline operations by applying task mining to back-office processes. This approach reveals opportunities for automation, such as repetitive data entry tasks, which reduces errors and saves significant time—up to 40% in some cases.

Remote and Hybrid Workplaces. For organizations with remote or hybrid teams, task mining offers a clear understanding of how employees use digital tools. These insights guide adjustments to workflows and systems, enhancing productivity and collaboration in distributed work environments.

Sales Operations. Task mining tracks the time sales teams dedicate to CRM updates, proposal generation, and email communication. When excessive time spent on CRM updates is identified, organizations adopt automated data-entry features, freeing up to 10 hours per week for sales representatives to focus on high-value activities.

When to Use Time Studies

Despite their limitations, time studies can still play a valuable role in certain scenarios and are particularly useful in environments where physical or manual tasks are dominant, or where understanding specific, routine workflows is critical:

Small to Medium-Sized Businesses (SMBs). For organizations with limited digital complexity, traditional time studies can provide actionable insights without requiring significant investment in technology.

Physical or Manual Work Environments. In industries like manufacturing, logistics, or healthcare, where tasks are predominantly physical, time studies can effectively capture workflow patterns and identify inefficiencies.

Pilot or Preliminary Assessments. Time studies can serve as an initial step in understanding basic productivity trends before investing in advanced tools like task mining.

Custom or Specialized Processes. For unique or non-standardized workflows, time studies may be more effective in capturing task nuances that automated tools might overlook.

If we focus by industry time studies can benefit:

Manufacturing Workflow Optimization. In an assembly factory, a time study can determine how long each step of the line takes and make a first draft of the current process map. The goal is to identify bottlenecks and optimize task sequences to improve production efficiency. 

Retail Checkout Process Improvement. A retail store conducts a time study to measure how long replenishers take to process pallets and distribute during peak hours.

Food Service Efficiency. A restaurant could evaluate how long servers take to complete various tasks like taking orders, delivering food, and clearing tables. The findings could lead to better task delegation and scheduling, reducing customer wait times during peak hours.

How Task Mining and Time Studies Can Complement Each Other

Rather than viewing time studies and task mining as competing approaches, organizations can combine them to maximize productivity insights.

Layering Depth and Breadth. Use time studies for in-depth analysis of specific tasks, particularly in physical work settings. Employ task mining for a broader, real-time understanding of digital workflows.

Iterative Improvement. Begin with time studies to identify preliminary bottlenecks and use task mining to continuously monitor improvements.

Hybrid Environments. For businesses with both physical and digital components (e.g., retail operations), time studies can complement task mining by covering the full spectrum of workflows.

Benchmarking and Validation. Task mining data can validate the findings of time studies, ensuring that recommendations are robust and actionable.

Combined Application Example

Retail Chain Workforce Optimization. Time studies evaluate how long employees spend on physical tasks like stocking shelves and assisting customers, while task mining analyzes digital tasks like inventory tracking and point-of-sale transactions.

Hybrid Work Environment Efficiency. An accountancy firm uses time studies to evaluate the time spent in physical meetings and task mining to analyze how employees use collaborative tools like MS Teams and email.

The Role of Transparency and Communication

Implementing task mining or any form of workplace analysis requires careful consideration of employee trust and engagement.

Be Transparent About Intentions. Clearly explain the goals of task mining or time studies, emphasizing their role in improving workflows and reducing inefficiencies rather than monitoring individual performance.

Engage Employees Early. Involve employees in the planning process, allowing them to voice concerns and provide input on how data will be used.

Focus on Collective Benefits. Highlight how the insights will benefit the team as a whole, such as by reducing repetitive tasks or improving work-life balance.

Ensure Privacy and Compliance. Implement tools that prioritize privacy, ensuring compliance with GDPR or other relevant regulations.

Communicate Results and Actions. Share the findings with employees and outline how the data will be used to make meaningful improvements. This fosters trust and collaboration.

Conclusion

While traditional time studies have limitations in the modern workplace, they can still be effective in specific contexts, particularly when combined with advanced tools like task mining. By leveraging the strengths of both approaches, organisations can gain a comprehensive understanding of productivity, streamline workflows, and foster a more efficient and engaged workforce.

However, the success of any productivity initiative depends on transparency, communication, and a commitment to ethical data use. When employees understand the purpose and benefits of these methodologies, they are more likely to embrace them, paving the way for meaningful and lasting improvements.

Contact Bestrateo to switch your strategy in operations and management.